Now Playing - Jenn Wilson-Until 3pm
← Back to Blog

Sugar Spat Sparks Sword Standoff

By Thom Watts·November 19, 2026

Sugar Spat Sparks Sword Standoff Menards

The coffee was bitter, but the living arrangement? Unsweetenable.

In North Fort Myers, Robert Mathias allegedly helped himself to his roommate’s sugar. The roommate objected. A reasonable next move? Apologize. Replace it. Buy your own tiny bag of domestic peace.

Deputies say Mathias went with a katana.

Yes. A sword. For a sugar dispute. Somewhere, a teaspoon wondered why it even bothered showing up.

The roommate told deputies he’d just finished making coffee when Mathias approached, held the blade inches from his face, and ordered him to back away.

Nothing complements a fresh roast coffee like the sudden possibility of becoming deli meat.

And because we don’t want to waste a chance to highlight the irony, this allegedly happened off Harmony Avenue.

Mathias was taken to Lee County Jail, facing a charge of aggravated assault with a weapon.

All over sugar. 

Photo: Lee County Sheriff's Office

Southwest Waste Service Quapaw Casino New Location
Classic Hits 93.9

Classic Hits 93.9

Playing the Greatest Hits of All Time! On Air